Representing Victims of Medical Malpractice Across Ontario

Miller v Noel: Tunnel Vision in the Emergency Room and a Fatal Case of Endocarditis

A 50-year-old millwright went to a Goderich emergency department after more than a month of coughing and shortness of breath, and was sent home with a diagnosis of post-viral cough. Nine days later he died of infective endocarditis. In Miller v Noel, the Superior Court held the emergency physician liable, admitting the patient's own account of the visit and rebuilding causation one step at a time.

By Paul Cahill November 19, 2026 10 min read
Navy title card reading "Miller v Noel: Emergency physician liable in a fatal endocarditis case" from paulcahill.ca

This is a trial decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, released October 27, 2026. Costs had not been decided when this was written, and the decision may still be appealed.

On a Saturday morning in January 2015, Michael Miller went to the emergency department in Goderich after more than a month of coughing and shortness of breath. He was 50 and worked as a millwright at the local salt mine. The emergency physician diagnosed a post-viral cough, ordered no tests and sent him home. Nine days later, Mr. Miller was found dead in his bed. The autopsy showed infective endocarditis, a bacterial infection of the heart’s inner lining and valves, on a bicuspid aortic valve no one knew he had.

In Miller v Noel, 2026 ONSC 6085, Justice Jasminka Kalajdzic held the emergency physician, Dr. Daniel Noel, liable for the death. The decision addresses three recurring problems in emergency department cases: proving what happened in the examination room when the patient cannot testify, deciding what a brief chart proves, and proving causation when the tests that would have answered the question were never done.

The Facts

Over December and January, Mr. Miller coughed constantly, turned grey, lost his appetite and energy, and lost enough weight that his clothes hung on him. The court found he had lost at least 25 to 30 pounds. His spouse gave uncontested evidence that he was short of breath when lying down.

At triage on January 24, 2015, he reported a productive cough for a month and shortness of breath on exertion. His temperature was normal, his pulse slightly elevated at 103, and he was triaged as less urgent. Dr. Noel, a local family physician and hospitalist who covered emergency shifts, saw him at 10:30 a.m.; the records show discharge at 10:45 a.m. Mr. Miller was told the cough would settle with rest and fluids, and to return if he was worried, worse or had new symptoms.

He kept working that week. On February 2, during a snowstorm, he stayed home with vomiting and diarrhea and planned to go to hospital the next day. He died early on February 3. The infection had formed a four-centimetre mass of infected tissue (a vegetation) and an abscess, and had eroded a hole in his aortic valve, causing sudden heart failure.

Damages had been resolved, so the trial was about liability only. The family did not argue that endocarditis should have been diagnosed that morning. Their case was that Dr. Noel failed to take a proper history, examine Mr. Miller properly, and order the basic tests needed to rule out a heart or lung cause.

A Patient’s Words After His Death

Within a day or two of the visit, Mr. Miller told his spouse, his best friend and his sister that the doctor had not listened to his chest. The court admitted those statements for their truth under the principled exception to the hearsay rule. Necessity was conceded. On reliability, the statements were made within days about a short one-on-one encounter, two were volunteered without prompting, and the court rejected the suggested motive to lie. Mr. Miller was private about his health, and telling his family the doctor had not examined him was bound to bring more pressure to see a doctor. The court distinguished Conn v Darcel, 2013 ONSC 5080, where a patient had reason to downplay his cardiologist’s warnings to his spouse.

The court was careful about the limits. Repeating a statement to several people does not corroborate it, and the statement to his sister carried less weight because she had asked the question. Nor was the court satisfied by the evidence of his spouse’s daughter, a registered practical nurse, that she had heard crackles in his lungs with a novelty stethoscope at a family dinner.

The Chart Entry Written After the Patient Left

Dr. Noel admitted that he wrote the last lines of his brief note, including chest clear all fields, at the charting station after Mr. Miller had left the room. The family suggested the lines were added later, possibly after the death. The court rejected that allegation: altering a chart after a death is a serious charge requiring clear, convincing and cogent evidence, and the evidence indicated the chart would have been scanned well before Mr. Miller died.

The court nonetheless found that the entry did not reflect what happened. Dr. Noel described a firm memory of the encounter, but his trial evidence in 2026 departed from his 2019 discovery evidence on several material points, including what he asked about shortness of breath when lying flat, what his note of no dyspnea meant, and whether he told Mr. Miller to return if short of breath. Given the thin chart and those inconsistencies, the court gave his account little weight and found that he did not listen to Mr. Miller’s heart and lungs.

Where the Standard of Care Was Breached

Both standard of care experts were qualified in emergency medicine: Dr. Edwin Brankston for the family and Dr. Michael Marriott for the defence. The defence expert agreed that for a 50-year-old man with a month-long cough and shortness of breath on exertion, the must-not-miss diagnoses included cancer and infection, and that fatigue, weight loss and the type of shortness of breath had to be explored.

The court found four breaches. Dr. Noel did not adequately explore the shortness of breath, including whether it occurred lying down, how long it had lasted or whether Mr. Miller’s walking tolerance had changed, so he could not rule out a cardiac cause. He asked about weight loss only within a rapid-fire compound question that was not clear enough to be understood, and did not ask about cold remedies that can lower a fever. He did not listen to the chest, although the defence expert agreed anyone with a month-long cough should be auscultated. And he ordered no chest X-ray, bloodwork or electrocardiogram (ECG), tests Dr. Brankston described as basic emergency care available even in small community hospitals.

The defence expert’s view that no tests were needed rested on Dr. Noel’s account of the history, which the court did not accept, so it carried less weight. The court concluded that a diagnosis of post-viral cough at the peak of cold and flu season was “more likely the result of tunnel vision” than of a reasonable clinical assessment. Not every criticism succeeded: documentation of each question, an inhaler and the return instructions themselves were not breaches. The problem was the diagnosis behind the instructions.

Causation: Reconstructing Nine Days That Never Happened

The family had to prove that Mr. Miller more likely than not would have survived with proper care. The court applied the but-for test as restated by the Supreme Court of Canada in Hemmings v Padmore, released four days earlier, and noted that a defendant cannot rely on missing test results his own breach created, as the Court of Appeal held in Hasan v Trillium.

Working through competing expert evidence, the court found that bloodwork that day would likely have shown an elevated white blood cell count, a chest X-ray would have shown an enlarged heart, and an ECG would have been flagged abnormal. A heart murmur was present, and the family’s cardiologist, who teaches auscultation, testified that any medical graduate would have heard it. Those findings would have led to blood cultures that turned positive the next day, intravenous antibiotics from January 25, and an echocardiogram by January 27 showing the vegetation. Diagnosis would have meant admission to London Health Sciences Centre by January 28, a transesophageal echocardiogram by January 30, and surgery no later than February 1.

The defence argued an echocardiogram would have taken two to four weeks at a small hospital and suggested the local internist may have been away. But Mr. Miller’s spouse, seen for fainting less than a week after his death, had a non-urgent echocardiogram within three days. The defence called no evidence about the internist’s availability, and the court drew an adverse inference, relying on Ibrahimova v Cavanagh, where similar reasoning was upheld on appeal this year.

On survival, the family’s cardiac surgeon put Mr. Miller’s chance of surviving surgery at 80 to 90 percent using a published risk score, and the defence cardiac surgeon agreed he likely would have survived if diagnosed before February 3. The court rejected the argument that surgery would have waited until the infection cleared, accepting evidence based on American Heart Association guidelines (a US clinical practice guideline, as it stood in 2015) that support early surgery where there is an abscess.

The Contributory Negligence Argument

The defence argued that Mr. Miller was 50 percent to blame for not returning sooner. The court found the defence had not met its burden. He had been told to rest and let the illness run its course, with no timeline for returning, and Dr. Noel agreed that waiting seven to ten days was not wrong. The only new symptoms came on February 2, in a snowstorm, and the defence’s own surgeon agreed it was reasonable to stay home. There was also no evidence that a visit that day could have led to surgery in time. The court distinguished Peppler Estate v Lee, 2019 ABQB 144, aff’d 2020 ABCA 282, 11 Alta. L.R. (7th) 215, an Alberta case (persuasive only in Ontario) where a patient ignored months of dramatically worsening symptoms.

Why This Decision Matters

As a trial decision, Miller v Noel does not bind other Superior Court judges, but it applies settled appellate principles to a very common scenario: a patient with a lingering cough sent home in flu season. A patient’s own account of a visit can survive his death and decide a case where the circumstances leave no real motive to lie. A brief chart invites closer scrutiny of a physician’s later recollection, and an expert opinion is only as strong as the facts it assumes. And delayed diagnosis claims turn on causation proven at every link; here that took infectious diseases, internal medicine, cardiology and cardiac surgery experts, plus evidence of how referrals worked at the regional hospital in 2015.

The defence position deserves a fair statement. The family conceded that endocarditis could not have been diagnosed that day. Mr. Miller’s vital signs were largely normal and he had no fever at triage. The finding that no chest examination occurred rests on hearsay the court found had no permissible corroboration. Key causation links were contested: an infectious diseases textbook the family’s own expert accepted as authoritative describes an elevated white count as rare in this form of endocarditis, two defence experts said a systolic murmur would not have been detectable, and the timeline put surgery no later than February 1 against a fatal rupture overnight on February 2. Any appeal would likely target those points, although appellate courts generally defer to a trial judge’s credibility findings and choices between experts.

Practical Lessons for Patients and Families

  • Describe changes, not just symptoms. Weight loss, trouble breathing when lying down and doing less than usual all matter. Mention cold or flu medicines you have taken, since some lower a fever.
  • Ask what has been ruled out. After weeks of coughing, it is reasonable to ask whether your heart and lungs were checked and whether tests are needed.
  • Ask when to come back. Ask how long recovery should take and which symptoms mean you should return sooner.
  • Write things down. If a family member describes an appointment to you, note what they said and when. Here, what Mr. Miller told his family within days was central.
  • Get advice early. Ontario’s limitation periods are strict.

Speak With Paul Cahill

If someone you love died or was seriously harmed after being sent home from an emergency department, Paul Cahill can review what happened, what the records show and whether qualified experts are likely to support a claim. Paul is a partner at Davidson Cahill Morrison LLP and is certified by the Law Society of Ontario as a Specialist in Civil Litigation. Every case depends on its own facts and expert evidence. To arrange a confidential consultation, contact Paul.

Miller v Noel, 2026 ONSC 6085.

Filed under:
Continue Reading

More on medical malpractice in Ontario.

Other articles by Paul exploring the conditions, decisions, and systems behind preventable medical harm.