
Sutherland v Booth: A Tragic Stroke Case Defeated on the Expert Evidence
A 27-year-old woman died from a missed cerebellar stroke after an ER discharge. The malpractice claim was dismissed when the plaintiff’s expert evidence unravelled at trial.
Representing Victims of Medical Malpractice Across Ontario

A 27-year-old woman died from a missed cerebellar stroke after an ER discharge. The malpractice claim was dismissed when the plaintiff’s expert evidence unravelled at trial.

Paul Cahill’s article on expert witness qualification was published in the Winter 2023/2024 edition of The Litigator, OTLA’s flagship publication.

Three 2023 decisions from Alberta, Ontario, and Newfoundland show why self-represented plaintiffs almost never succeed in medical malpractice litigation.

A Northern Ontario ER physician was found guilty of misconduct and separately found incompetent for sustained COVID-19 misinformation across a two-year period.

A self-represented plaintiff’s Lyme disease delayed-diagnosis claim was dismissed at summary judgment after his sole expert witness was disqualified.
Free, confidential consultations. Paul reviews every potential case personally and tells you honestly whether it merits investigation.